Benchmarks on Sergey/kcfa/kcfa-worst-case-20.scm of differents structure for the worklist (Scala-Par-AM 01.00.02)

TypeSet lattice – Classical address – Default step – Sequential SeqAAMLS and parallel ParAAM-*-*-* without ParAAMCSState – 13 repetitions (time in seconds, computed on Bertha – Intel Xeon CPU E5-2637 v3 @ 3.50GHz – 2 processors × 4 cores × 2 by Hyper-Threading – Java GraalVM 19.1.1)
  Machine p # states # error states # error values # final states # final values Final values # ? Time 1 ? Time 2 ? Time 3 ? Time 4 ? Time 5 ? Time 6 ? Time 7 ? Time 8 ? Time 9 ? Time 10 ? Time 11 ? Time 12 ? Time 13 # finished Average time Standard error Correct? Error 1 Error 2 Error 3 Error 4 Error 5 Error 6 Error 7 Error 8 Error 9 Error 10 Error 11 Error 12 Error 13
1 SeqAAMLS 1 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 1.702 ✓ 1.463 ✓ 1.47  ✓ 1.362 ✓ 1.357 ✓ 1.498 ✓ 1.448 ✓ 1.346 ✓ 1.349 ✓ 1.401 ✓ 1.405 ✓ 1.427 ✓ 1.433 13 1.435 0.062 ✓
2 ParAAM-L-SA-state 2 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.088 ✓ 3.352 ✓ 3.034 ✓ 3.066 ✓ 3.048 ✓ 3.047 ✓ 3.109 ✓ 3.113 ✓ 3.17  ✓ 3.057 ✓ 3.059 ✓ 3.04  ✓ 3.184 13 3.105 0.062 ✓
3 ParAAM-L-SA-state 3 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.185 ✓ 3.089 ✓ 3.112 ✓ 3.206 ✓ 3.097 ✓ 3.175 ✓ 3.146 ✓ 3.178 ✓ 3.031 ✓ 3.066 ✓ 3.115 ✓ 3.207 ✓ 3.126 13 3.133 0.046 ✓
4 ParAAM-L-SA-state 4 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.072 ✓ 3.135 ✓ 3.085 ✓ 3.03  ✓ 3.122 ✓ 3.128 ✓ 3.011 ✓ 3.123 ✓ 3.058 ✓ 3.078 ✓ 3.08  ✓ 3.054 ✓ 3.089 13 3.082 0.029 ✓
5 ParAAM-L-SA-state 5 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.099 ✓ 3.056 ✓ 3.046 ✓ 3.019 ✓ 3.073 ✓ 3.044 ✓ 3.073 ✓ 3.02  ✓ 3.124 ✓ 3.044 ✓ 3.044 ✓ 3.276 ✓ 3.077 13 3.076 0.042 ✓
6 ParAAM-L-SA-state 6 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.096 ✓ 3.179 ✓ 3.065 ✓ 3.03  ✓ 3.072 ✓ 3.057 ✓ 3.195 ✓ 2.988 ✓ 3.173 ✓ 3.055 ✓ 3.042 ✓ 3.039 ✓ 3.052 13 3.08  0.05  ✓
7 ParAAM-L-SA-state 7 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.115 ✓ 3.074 ✓ 3.14  ✓ 3.111 ✓ 3.175 ✓ 3.197 ✓ 3.068 ✓ 3.107 ✓ 3.01  ✓ 3.074 ✓ 3.105 ✓ 3.035 ✓ 3.106 13 3.101 0.038 ✓
8 ParAAM-L-SA-state 8 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.191 ✓ 3.072 ✓ 3.177 ✓ 3.067 ✓ 3.1   ✓ 3.086 ✓ 3.097 ✓ 3.036 ✓ 3.01  ✓ 3.079 ✓ 3.083 ✓ 3.076 ✓ 3.042 13 3.086 0.034 ✓
9 ParAAM-L-SA-state 9 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.009 ✓ 3.096 ✓ 3.183 ✓ 3.105 ✓ 3.092 ✓ 3.053 ✓ 3.111 ✓ 3.06  ✓ 3.09  ✓ 3.078 ✓ 3.135 ✓ 2.996 ✓ 3.057 13 3.082 0.037 ✓
10 ParAAM-L-SA-state 10 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.1   ✓ 3.177 ✓ 3.038 ✓ 3.152 ✓ 3.087 ✓ 3.025 ✓ 3.116 ✓ 3.066 ✓ 3.111 ✓ 3.113 ✓ 3.01  ✓ 3.092 ✓ 3.03  13 3.086 0.04  ✓
11 ParAAM-L-SA-state 12 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.101 ✓ 3.112 ✓ 3.128 ✓ 3.071 ✓ 3.1   ✓ 3.075 ✓ 3.147 ✓ 3.055 ✓ 3.092 ✓ 2.979 ✓ 3.05  ✓ 3.079 ✓ 3.076 13 3.082 0.029 ✓
12 ParAAM-L-SA-state 14 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.072 ✓ 3.095 ✓ 3.105 ✓ 3.072 ✓ 3.026 ✓ 3.039 ✓ 2.995 ✓ 3.056 ✓ 3.051 ✓ 3.097 ✓ 3.078 ✓ 3.069 ✓ 3.011 13 3.059 0.027 ✓
13 ParAAM-L-SA-state 16 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.188 ✓ 3.205 ✓ 3.128 ✓ 3.138 ✓ 3.09  ✓ 3.135 ✓ 2.993 ✓ 3.065 ✓ 3.071 ✓ 3.039 ✓ 3.075 ✓ 3.228 ✓ 2.976 13 3.102 0.063 ✓
14 ParAAM-L-SA-state 24 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.113 ✓ 3.104 ✓ 3.106 ✓ 3.164 ✓ 3.101 ✓ 3.052 ✓ 3.128 ✓ 3.108 ✓ 3.069 ✓ 3.093 ✓ 2.995 ✓ 3.075 ✓ 3.108 13 3.094 0.028 ✓
15 ParAAM-L-SA-state 32 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.169 ✓ 3.058 ✓ 3.119 ✓ 3.135 ✓ 3.07  ✓ 3.158 ✓ 3.215 ✓ 3.11  ✓ 3.179 ✓ 3.072 ✓ 3.057 ✓ 3.084 ✓ 3.073 13 3.115 0.044 ✓
16 ParAAM-L-SA-set 2 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.116 ✓ 3.056 ✓ 3.02  ✓ 3.021 ✓ 3.087 ✓ 3.152 ✓ 3.037 ✓ 3.03  ✓ 2.991 ✓ 3.092 ✓ 3.029 ✓ 3.011 ✓ 3.014 13 3.05  0.039 ✓
17 ParAAM-L-SA-set 3 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.123 ✓ 3.07  ✓ 3.2   ✓ 3.162 ✓ 3.095 ✓ 3.093 ✓ 3.054 ✓ 3.026 ✓ 3.06  ✓ 3.059 ✓ 3.043 ✓ 3.045 ✓ 3.035 13 3.082 0.04  ✓
18 ParAAM-L-SA-set 4 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.113 ✓ 3.129 ✓ 3.008 ✓ 3.058 ✓ 3.125 ✓ 3.052 ✓ 3.078 ✓ 3.088 ✓ 3.059 ✓ 3.078 ✓ 3.091 ✓ 3.203 ✓ 3.109 13 3.091 0.034 ✓
19 ParAAM-L-SA-set 5 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.116 ✓ 3.107 ✓ 3.047 ✓ 3.045 ✓ 3.034 ✓ 3.078 ✓ 3.087 ✓ 3.088 ✓ 3.086 ✓ 3.11  ✓ 3.146 ✓ 3.087 ✓ 3.078 13 3.085 0.022 ✓
20 ParAAM-L-SA-set 6 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.098 ✓ 3.062 ✓ 3.104 ✓ 3.081 ✓ 3.036 ✓ 3.1   ✓ 3.076 ✓ 3.167 ✓ 3.066 ✓ 3.199 ✓ 3.088 ✓ 3.132 ✓ 3.07  13 3.098 0.032 ✓
21 ParAAM-L-SA-set 7 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.14  ✓ 3.056 ✓ 3.071 ✓ 3.087 ✓ 3.055 ✓ 3.128 ✓ 3.094 ✓ 3.126 ✓ 3.197 ✓ 3.11  ✓ 3.09  ✓ 3.145 ✓ 3.056 13 3.104 0.034 ✓
22 ParAAM-L-SA-set 8 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.136 ✓ 3.103 ✓ 3.033 ✓ 3.095 ✓ 3.089 ✓ 3.134 ✓ 3.037 ✓ 3.088 ✓ 3.107 ✓ 3.091 ✓ 3.052 ✓ 3.09  ✓ 3.098 13 3.089 0.022 ✓
23 ParAAM-L-SA-set 9 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.121 ✓ 3.054 ✓ 3.078 ✓ 3.105 ✓ 3.127 ✓ 3.028 ✓ 3.146 ✓ 3.093 ✓ 3.148 ✓ 3.119 ✓ 3.11  ✓ 3.094 ✓ 3.14  13 3.105 0.027 ✓
24 ParAAM-L-SA-set 10 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.133 ✓ 3.068 ✓ 3.091 ✓ 3.088 ✓ 3.014 ✓ 3.031 ✓ 3.148 ✓ 3.194 ✓ 3.101 ✓ 3.01  ✓ 3.147 ✓ 3.035 ✓ 3.071 13 3.087 0.045 ✓
25 ParAAM-L-SA-set 12 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.116 ✓ 3.092 ✓ 3.01  ✓ 3.109 ✓ 3.074 ✓ 3.129 ✓ 3.09  ✓ 3.119 ✓ 3.086 ✓ 3.078 ✓ 3.213 ✓ 3.046 ✓ 3.053 13 3.093 0.034 ✓
26 ParAAM-L-SA-set 14 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.113 ✓ 3.095 ✓ 3.093 ✓ 3.05  ✓ 3.124 ✓ 3.107 ✓ 3.092 ✓ 3.123 ✓ 3.087 ✓ 3.042 ✓ 3.103 ✓ 3.08  ✓ 3.048 13 3.089 0.021 ✓
27 ParAAM-L-SA-set 16 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.141 ✓ 3.155 ✓ 3.102 ✓ 3.042 ✓ 3.165 ✓ 3.147 ✓ 3.084 ✓ 3.095 ✓ 3.08  ✓ 3.105 ✓ 3.128 ✓ 2.766 ✓ 2.884 13 3.069 0.079 ✓
28 ParAAM-L-SA-set 24 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.072 ✓ 3.085 ✓ 3.031 ✓ 3.138 ✓ 3.104 ✓ 3.184 ✓ 3.083 ✓ 3.093 ✓ 3.097 ✓ 3.12  ✓ 3.245 ✓ 3.063 ✓ 3.193 13 3.116 0.046 ✓
29 ParAAM-L-SA-set 32 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 3.14  ✓ 3.077 ✓ 3.127 ✓ 3.106 ✓ 3.062 ✓ 3.083 ✓ 3.005 ✓ 3.084 ✓ 3.037 ✓ 3.071 ✓ 3.096 ✓ 3.005 ✓ 3.125 13 3.078 0.033 ✓
30 ParAAM-L-SA-part 2 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 2.441 ✓ 2.522 ✓ 2.538 ✓ 2.44  ✓ 2.397 ✓ 2.312 ✓ 2.312 ✓ 2.431 ✓ 2.395 ✓ 2.316 ✓ 2.48  ✓ 2.386 ✓ 2.324 13 2.407 0.063 ✓
31 ParAAM-L-SA-part 3 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 1.995 ✓ 1.952 ✓ 1.851 ✓ 1.945 ✓ 1.944 ✓ 1.803 ✓ 1.925 ✓ 1.862 ✓ 1.887 ✓ 1.93  ✓ 1.923 ✓ 1.891 ✓ 1.948 13 1.912 0.041 ✓
32 ParAAM-L-SA-part 4 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 1.798 ✓ 1.747 ✓ 1.774 ✓ 1.734 ✓ 1.76  ✓ 1.719 ✓ 1.758 ✓ 1.714 ✓ 1.745 ✓ 1.717 ✓ 1.721 ✓ 1.729 ✓ 1.767 13 1.745 0.021 ✓
33 ParAAM-L-SA-part 5 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 1.682 ✓ 1.646 ✓ 1.606 ✓ 1.635 ✓ 1.631 ✓ 1.624 ✓ 1.614 ✓ 1.647 ✓ 1.63  ✓ 1.66  ✓ 1.661 ✓ 1.63  ✓ 1.653 13 1.64  0.017 ✓
34 ParAAM-L-SA-part 6 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 1.594 ✓ 1.567 ✓ 1.554 ✓ 1.559 ✓ 1.544 ✓ 1.558 ✓ 1.568 ✓ 1.545 ✓ 1.546 ✓ 1.551 ✓ 1.576 ✓ 1.596 ✓ 1.528 13 1.56  0.015 ✓
35 ParAAM-L-SA-part 7 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 1.469 ✓ 1.444 ✓ 1.523 ✓ 1.435 ✓ 1.454 ✓ 1.474 ✓ 1.455 ✓ 1.446 ✓ 1.457 ✓ 1.467 ✓ 1.441 ✓ 1.433 ✓ 1.456 13 1.458 0.016 ✓
36 ParAAM-L-SA-part 8 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 1.467 ✓ 1.429 ✓ 1.422 ✓ 1.402 ✓ 1.396 ✓ 1.413 ✓ 1.399 ✓ 1.426 ✓ 1.41  ✓ 1.41  ✓ 1.404 ✓ 1.421 ✓ 1.421 13 1.417 0.013 ✓
37 ParAAM-L-SA-part 9 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 1.487 ✓ 1.43  ✓ 1.423 ✓ 1.442 ✓ 1.438 ✓ 1.431 ✓ 1.423 ✓ 1.44  ✓ 1.423 ✓ 1.41  ✓ 1.414 ✓ 1.436 ✓ 1.434 13 1.433 0.012 ✓
38 ParAAM-L-SA-part 10 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 1.567 ✓ 1.553 ✓ 1.569 ✓ 1.577 ✓ 1.509 ✓ 1.525 ✓ 1.523 ✓ 1.537 ✓ 1.537 ✓ 1.581 ✓ 1.55  ✓ 1.53  ✓ 1.496 13 1.543 0.022 ✓
39 ParAAM-L-SA-part 12 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 1.65  ✓ 1.608 ✓ 1.581 ✓ 1.581 ✓ 1.587 ✓ 1.595 ✓ 1.597 ✓ 1.597 ✓ 1.59  ✓ 1.586 ✓ 1.593 ✓ 1.601 ✓ 1.569 13 1.595 0.012 ✓
40 ParAAM-L-SA-part 14 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 1.682 ✓ 1.614 ✓ 1.623 ✓ 1.666 ✓ 1.667 ✓ 1.644 ✓ 1.659 ✓ 1.657 ✓ 1.656 ✓ 1.667 ✓ 1.644 ✓ 1.639 ✓ 1.645 13 1.651 0.015 ✓
41 ParAAM-L-SA-part 16 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 1.729 ✓ 1.742 ✓ 1.724 ✓ 1.686 ✓ 1.706 ✓ 1.719 ✓ 1.687 ✓ 1.694 ✓ 1.712 ✓ 1.732 ✓ 1.74  ✓ 1.687 ✓ 1.693 13 1.712 0.018 ✓
42 ParAAM-L-SA-part 24 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 1.981 ✓ 1.904 ✓ 1.911 ✓ 1.914 ✓ 1.896 ✓ 1.936 ✓ 1.927 ✓ 1.919 ✓ 1.913 ✓ 1.932 ✓ 1.958 ✓ 1.943 ✓ 1.929 13 1.928 0.017 ✓
43 ParAAM-L-SA-part 32 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 2.317 ✓ 2.213 ✓ 2.206 ✓ 2.21  ✓ 2.197 ✓ 2.223 ✓ 2.246 ✓ 2.232 ✓ 2.22  ✓ 2.255 ✓ 2.305 ✓ 2.217 ✓ 2.22  13 2.235 0.028 ✓
44 ParAAM-C-S-set 2 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 2.63  ✓ 2.401 ✓ 2.613 ✓ 2.467 ✓ 2.434 ✓ 2.555 ✓ 2.47  ✓ 2.376 ✓ 2.328 ✓ 2.464 ✓ 2.482 ✓ 2.328 ✓ 2.366 13 2.455 0.076 ✓
45 ParAAM-C-S-set 3 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 1.539 ✓ 1.494 ✓ 1.478 ✓ 1.509 ✓ 1.463 ✓ 1.48  ✓ 1.46  ✓ 1.463 ✓ 1.459 ✓ 1.475 ✓ 1.445 ✓ 1.442 ✓ 1.49  13 1.477 0.02  ✓
46 ParAAM-C-S-set 4 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 1.035 ✓ 0.986 ✓ 0.969 ✓ 0.973 ✓ 0.985 ✓ 0.976 ✓ 0.991 ✓ 0.983 ✓ 0.997 ✓ 0.983 ✓ 0.991 ✓ 0.978 ✓ 0.997 13 0.988 0.011 ✓
47 ParAAM-C-S-set 5 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.761 ✓ 0.761 ✓ 0.72  ✓ 0.727 ✓ 0.73  ✓ 0.731 ✓ 0.72  ✓ 0.718 ✓ 0.723 ✓ 0.719 ✓ 0.735 ✓ 0.728 ✓ 0.759 13 0.733 0.013 ✓
48 ParAAM-C-S-set 6 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.6   ✓ 0.584 ✓ 0.613 ✓ 0.586 ✓ 0.576 ✓ 0.584 ✓ 0.6   ✓ 0.577 ✓ 0.573 ✓ 0.589 ✓ 0.601 ✓ 0.583 ✓ 0.568 13 0.587 0.01  ✓
49 ParAAM-C-S-set 7 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.641 ✓ 0.553 ✓ 0.57  ✓ 0.608 ✓ 0.603 ✓ 0.678 ✓ 0.781 ✓ 0.572 ✓ 0.569 ✓ 0.638 ✓ 0.578 ✓ 0.526 ✓ 0.598 13 0.609 0.047 ✓
50 ParAAM-C-S-set 8 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.53  ✓ 0.484 ✓ 0.515 ✓ 0.593 ✓ 0.542 ✓ 0.559 ✓ 0.546 ✓ 0.527 ✓ 0.496 ✓ 0.677 ✓ 0.47  ✓ 0.487 ✓ 0.455 13 0.529 0.042 ✓
51 ParAAM-C-S-set 9 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.581 ✓ 0.512 ✓ 0.438 ✓ 0.58  ✓ 0.445 ✓ 0.448 ✓ 0.431 ✓ 0.432 ✓ 0.47  ✓ 0.457 ✓ 0.525 ✓ 0.447 ✓ 0.429 13 0.476 0.045 ✓
52 ParAAM-C-S-set 10 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.496 ✓ 0.445 ✓ 0.505 ✓ 0.412 ✓ 0.424 ✓ 0.468 ✓ 0.416 ✓ 0.477 ✓ 0.491 ✓ 0.441 ✓ 0.498 ✓ 0.44  ✓ 0.434 13 0.457 0.029 ✓
53 ParAAM-C-S-set 12 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.456 ✓ 0.422 ✓ 0.415 ✓ 0.403 ✓ 0.406 ✓ 0.419 ✓ 0.419 ✓ 0.405 ✓ 0.414 ✓ 0.402 ✓ 0.418 ✓ 0.399 ✓ 0.419 13 0.415 0.009 ✓
54 ParAAM-C-S-set 14 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.427 ✓ 0.405 ✓ 0.414 ✓ 0.406 ✓ 0.443 ✓ 0.4   ✓ 0.44  ✓ 0.425 ✓ 0.417 ✓ 0.396 ✓ 0.428 ✓ 0.405 ✓ 0.434 13 0.418 0.013 ✓
55 ParAAM-C-S-set 16 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.445 ✓ 0.439 ✓ 0.398 ✓ 0.396 ✓ 0.438 ✓ 0.392 ✓ 0.4   ✓ 0.406 ✓ 0.397 ✓ 0.397 ✓ 0.43  ✓ 0.44  ✓ 0.408 13 0.414 0.019 ✓
56 ParAAM-C-S-set 24 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.434 ✓ 0.418 ✓ 0.405 ✓ 0.413 ✓ 0.445 ✓ 0.452 ✓ 0.429 ✓ 0.452 ✓ 0.4   ✓ 0.428 ✓ 0.416 ✓ 0.403 ✓ 0.422 13 0.424 0.014 ✓
57 ParAAM-C-S-set 32 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.436 ✓ 0.402 ✓ 0.414 ✓ 0.41  ✓ 0.417 ✓ 0.421 ✓ 0.4   ✓ 0.405 ✓ 0.441 ✓ 0.452 ✓ 0.402 ✓ 0.401 ✓ 0.407 13 0.416 0.013 ✓
58 ParAAM-C-S-part 2 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 2.519 ✓ 2.34  ✓ 2.268 ✓ 2.283 ✓ 2.32  ✓ 2.294 ✓ 2.375 ✓ 2.305 ✓ 2.286 ✓ 2.32  ✓ 2.466 ✓ 2.311 ✓ 2.366 13 2.342 0.055 ✓
59 ParAAM-C-S-part 3 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 1.517 ✓ 1.455 ✓ 1.484 ✓ 1.466 ✓ 1.441 ✓ 1.43  ✓ 1.478 ✓ 1.491 ✓ 1.437 ✓ 1.484 ✓ 1.507 ✓ 1.439 ✓ 1.424 13 1.466 0.026 ✓
60 ParAAM-C-S-part 4 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 1.136 ✓ 1.102 ✓ 1.122 ✓ 1.133 ✓ 1.067 ✓ 1.095 ✓ 1.067 ✓ 1.115 ✓ 1.094 ✓ 1.114 ✓ 1.101 ✓ 1.083 ✓ 1.059 13 1.099 0.02  ✓
61 ParAAM-C-S-part 5 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.904 ✓ 0.827 ✓ 0.831 ✓ 0.858 ✓ 0.847 ✓ 0.846 ✓ 0.831 ✓ 0.851 ✓ 0.872 ✓ 0.876 ✓ 0.876 ✓ 0.851 ✓ 0.864 13 0.857 0.017 ✓
62 ParAAM-C-S-part 6 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.713 ✓ 0.695 ✓ 0.684 ✓ 0.682 ✓ 0.664 ✓ 0.694 ✓ 0.688 ✓ 0.678 ✓ 0.67  ✓ 0.687 ✓ 0.696 ✓ 0.687 ✓ 0.695 13 0.687 0.009 ✓
63 ParAAM-C-S-part 7 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.668 ✓ 0.58  ✓ 0.592 ✓ 0.574 ✓ 0.608 ✓ 0.647 ✓ 0.682 ✓ 0.6   ✓ 0.614 ✓ 0.594 ✓ 0.636 ✓ 0.594 ✓ 0.646 13 0.618 0.029 ✓
64 ParAAM-C-S-part 8 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.689 ✓ 0.686 ✓ 0.67  ✓ 0.65  ✓ 0.607 ✓ 0.669 ✓ 0.608 ✓ 0.619 ✓ 0.646 ✓ 0.712 ✓ 0.664 ✓ 0.654 ✓ 0.657 13 0.656 0.024 ✓
65 ParAAM-C-S-part 9 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.748 ✓ 0.606 ✓ 0.635 ✓ 0.664 ✓ 0.634 ✓ 0.675 ✓ 0.739 ✓ 0.709 ✓ 0.654 ✓ 0.653 ✓ 0.727 ✓ 0.656 ✓ 0.673 13 0.675 0.034 ✓
66 ParAAM-C-S-part 10 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.526 ✓ 0.529 ✓ 0.596 ✓ 0.591 ✓ 0.579 ✓ 0.561 ✓ 0.732 ✓ 0.614 ✓ 0.52  ✓ 0.542 ✓ 0.554 ✓ 0.648 ✓ 0.581 13 0.583 0.041 ✓
67 ParAAM-C-S-part 12 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.531 ✓ 0.503 ✓ 0.523 ✓ 0.575 ✓ 0.565 ✓ 0.494 ✓ 0.563 ✓ 0.518 ✓ 0.515 ✓ 0.5   ✓ 0.516 ✓ 0.487 ✓ 0.548 13 0.526 0.023 ✓
68 ParAAM-C-S-part 14 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.544 ✓ 0.497 ✓ 0.475 ✓ 0.502 ✓ 0.498 ✓ 0.518 ✓ 0.522 ✓ 0.471 ✓ 0.521 ✓ 0.497 ✓ 0.463 ✓ 0.489 ✓ 0.488 13 0.499 0.017 ✓
69 ParAAM-C-S-part 16 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.528 ✓ 0.469 ✓ 0.497 ✓ 0.464 ✓ 0.49  ✓ 0.491 ✓ 0.504 ✓ 0.509 ✓ 0.507 ✓ 0.487 ✓ 0.528 ✓ 0.468 ✓ 0.47  13 0.493 0.017 ✓
70 ParAAM-C-S-part 24 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.49  ✓ 0.432 ✓ 0.44  ✓ 0.426 ✓ 0.422 ✓ 0.456 ✓ 0.459 ✓ 0.493 ✓ 0.496 ✓ 0.472 ✓ 0.47  ✓ 0.422 ✓ 0.462 13 0.457 0.022 ✓
71 ParAAM-C-S-part 32 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.449 ✓ 0.454 ✓ 0.447 ✓ 0.421 ✓ 0.475 ✓ 0.428 ✓ 0.45  ✓ 0.505 ✓ 0.439 ✓ 0.474 ✓ 0.451 ✓ 0.419 ✓ 0.428 13 0.449 0.018 ✓
72 ParAAM-C-state 1 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 1.648 ✓ 1.502 ✓ 1.637 ✓ 1.513 ✓ 1.531 ✓ 1.469 ✓ 1.472 ✓ 1.53  ✓ 1.476 ✓ 1.483 ✓ 1.484 ✓ 1.591 ✓ 1.659 13 1.538 0.059 ✓
73 ParAAM-C-state 2 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.861 ✓ 0.819 ✓ 0.816 ✓ 0.816 ✓ 0.826 ✓ 0.823 ✓ 0.82  ✓ 0.817 ✓ 0.817 ✓ 0.807 ✓ 0.821 ✓ 0.814 ✓ 0.813 13 0.821 0.007 ✓
74 ParAAM-C-state 3 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.587 ✓ 0.569 ✓ 0.558 ✓ 0.58  ✓ 0.559 ✓ 0.548 ✓ 0.56  ✓ 0.575 ✓ 0.557 ✓ 0.567 ✓ 0.571 ✓ 0.57  ✓ 0.561 13 0.566 0.008 ✓
75 ParAAM-C-state 4 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.484 ✓ 0.45  ✓ 0.45  ✓ 0.472 ✓ 0.446 ✓ 0.451 ✓ 0.476 ✓ 0.453 ✓ 0.448 ✓ 0.448 ✓ 0.459 ✓ 0.45  ✓ 0.442 13 0.456 0.01  ✓
76 ParAAM-C-state 5 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.422 ✓ 0.382 ✓ 0.37  ✓ 0.374 ✓ 0.394 ✓ 0.392 ✓ 0.381 ✓ 0.377 ✓ 0.378 ✓ 0.382 ✓ 0.384 ✓ 0.39  ✓ 0.381 13 0.385 0.009 ✓
77 ParAAM-C-state 6 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.372 ✓ 0.335 ✓ 0.343 ✓ 0.35  ✓ 0.342 ✓ 0.345 ✓ 0.344 ✓ 0.345 ✓ 0.349 ✓ 0.345 ✓ 0.343 ✓ 0.331 ✓ 0.336 13 0.345 0.006 ✓
78 ParAAM-C-state 7 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.355 ✓ 0.307 ✓ 0.307 ✓ 0.309 ✓ 0.303 ✓ 0.314 ✓ 0.307 ✓ 0.303 ✓ 0.316 ✓ 0.315 ✓ 0.319 ✓ 0.311 ✓ 0.311 13 0.314 0.008 ✓
79 ParAAM-C-state 8 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.34  ✓ 0.312 ✓ 0.308 ✓ 0.307 ✓ 0.306 ✓ 0.309 ✓ 0.3   ✓ 0.308 ✓ 0.294 ✓ 0.31  ✓ 0.302 ✓ 0.313 ✓ 0.31  13 0.309 0.006 ✓
80 ParAAM-C-state 9 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.364 ✓ 0.361 ✓ 0.319 ✓ 0.327 ✓ 0.333 ✓ 0.335 ✓ 0.323 ✓ 0.366 ✓ 0.347 ✓ 0.32  ✓ 0.352 ✓ 0.322 ✓ 0.324 13 0.338 0.015 ✓
81 ParAAM-C-state 10 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.371 ✓ 0.324 ✓ 0.326 ✓ 0.336 ✓ 0.329 ✓ 0.332 ✓ 0.374 ✓ 0.354 ✓ 0.329 ✓ 0.344 ✓ 0.352 ✓ 0.341 ✓ 0.343 13 0.343 0.013 ✓
82 ParAAM-C-state 12 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.376 ✓ 0.359 ✓ 0.364 ✓ 0.352 ✓ 0.344 ✓ 0.389 ✓ 0.335 ✓ 0.39  ✓ 0.359 ✓ 0.348 ✓ 0.369 ✓ 0.354 ✓ 0.358 13 0.361 0.013 ✓
83 ParAAM-C-state 14 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.382 ✓ 0.341 ✓ 0.376 ✓ 0.358 ✓ 0.338 ✓ 0.348 ✓ 0.351 ✓ 0.362 ✓ 0.358 ✓ 0.333 ✓ 0.349 ✓ 0.354 ✓ 0.34  13 0.353 0.011 ✓
84 ParAAM-C-state 16 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.383 ✓ 0.355 ✓ 0.344 ✓ 0.35  ✓ 0.343 ✓ 0.367 ✓ 0.35  ✓ 0.351 ✓ 0.352 ✓ 0.335 ✓ 0.35  ✓ 0.349 ✓ 0.332 13 0.351 0.008 ✓
85 ParAAM-C-state 24 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.402 ✓ 0.347 ✓ 0.35  ✓ 0.358 ✓ 0.368 ✓ 0.348 ✓ 0.329 ✓ 0.373 ✓ 0.339 ✓ 0.347 ✓ 0.34  ✓ 0.359 ✓ 0.339 13 0.354 0.014 ✓
86 ParAAM-C-state 32 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.381 ✓ 0.379 ✓ 0.347 ✓ 0.342 ✓ 0.366 ✓ 0.356 ✓ 0.374 ✓ 0.358 ✓ 0.343 ✓ 0.34  ✓ 0.344 ✓ 0.366 ✓ 0.358 13 0.358 0.012 ✓
87 ParAAM-C-set 1 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 1.582 ✓ 1.482 ✓ 1.473 ✓ 1.469 ✓ 1.492 ✓ 1.482 ✓ 1.641 ✓ 1.539 ✓ 1.506 ✓ 1.468 ✓ 1.498 ✓ 1.624 ✓ 1.513 13 1.521 0.047 ✓
88 ParAAM-C-set 2 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.841 ✓ 0.818 ✓ 0.818 ✓ 0.827 ✓ 0.817 ✓ 0.808 ✓ 0.788 ✓ 0.847 ✓ 0.801 ✓ 0.811 ✓ 0.865 ✓ 0.825 ✓ 0.793 13 0.82  0.016 ✓
89 ParAAM-C-set 3 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.583 ✓ 0.567 ✓ 0.558 ✓ 0.556 ✓ 0.551 ✓ 0.565 ✓ 0.55  ✓ 0.566 ✓ 0.551 ✓ 0.555 ✓ 0.561 ✓ 0.559 ✓ 0.558 13 0.56  0.007 ✓
90 ParAAM-C-set 4 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.48  ✓ 0.445 ✓ 0.446 ✓ 0.445 ✓ 0.445 ✓ 0.457 ✓ 0.446 ✓ 0.444 ✓ 0.439 ✓ 0.443 ✓ 0.445 ✓ 0.453 ✓ 0.447 13 0.449 0.007 ✓
91 ParAAM-C-set 5 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.377 ✓ 0.377 ✓ 0.382 ✓ 0.369 ✓ 0.383 ✓ 0.383 ✓ 0.374 ✓ 0.378 ✓ 0.378 ✓ 0.387 ✓ 0.383 ✓ 0.366 ✓ 0.382 13 0.378 0.004 ✓
92 ParAAM-C-set 6 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.349 ✓ 0.345 ✓ 0.335 ✓ 0.346 ✓ 0.338 ✓ 0.344 ✓ 0.335 ✓ 0.335 ✓ 0.346 ✓ 0.334 ✓ 0.343 ✓ 0.352 ✓ 0.339 13 0.342 0.005 ✓
93 ParAAM-C-set 7 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.337 ✓ 0.309 ✓ 0.304 ✓ 0.306 ✓ 0.313 ✓ 0.31  ✓ 0.303 ✓ 0.308 ✓ 0.308 ✓ 0.302 ✓ 0.307 ✓ 0.305 ✓ 0.313 13 0.31  0.005 ✓
94 ParAAM-C-set 8 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.336 ✓ 0.312 ✓ 0.3   ✓ 0.302 ✓ 0.303 ✓ 0.316 ✓ 0.299 ✓ 0.304 ✓ 0.295 ✓ 0.301 ✓ 0.31  ✓ 0.298 ✓ 0.295 13 0.306 0.008 ✓
95 ParAAM-C-set 9 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.364 ✓ 0.33  ✓ 0.372 ✓ 0.34  ✓ 0.333 ✓ 0.34  ✓ 0.332 ✓ 0.34  ✓ 0.347 ✓ 0.344 ✓ 0.331 ✓ 0.344 ✓ 0.335 13 0.342 0.009 ✓
96 ParAAM-C-set 10 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.369 ✓ 0.377 ✓ 0.384 ✓ 0.357 ✓ 0.374 ✓ 0.357 ✓ 0.346 ✓ 0.353 ✓ 0.363 ✓ 0.346 ✓ 0.35  ✓ 0.349 ✓ 0.356 13 0.36  0.01  ✓
97 ParAAM-C-set 12 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.399 ✓ 0.357 ✓ 0.361 ✓ 0.361 ✓ 0.348 ✓ 0.342 ✓ 0.354 ✓ 0.347 ✓ 0.357 ✓ 0.362 ✓ 0.363 ✓ 0.355 ✓ 0.353 13 0.358 0.008 ✓
98 ParAAM-C-set 14 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.381 ✓ 0.357 ✓ 0.342 ✓ 0.386 ✓ 0.36  ✓ 0.353 ✓ 0.359 ✓ 0.349 ✓ 0.356 ✓ 0.354 ✓ 0.369 ✓ 0.343 ✓ 0.354 13 0.359 0.009 ✓
99 ParAAM-C-set 16 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.392 ✓ 0.361 ✓ 0.349 ✓ 0.346 ✓ 0.355 ✓ 0.351 ✓ 0.352 ✓ 0.346 ✓ 0.353 ✓ 0.368 ✓ 0.344 ✓ 0.364 ✓ 0.366 13 0.357 0.01  ✓
100 ParAAM-C-set 24 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.35  ✓ 0.336 ✓ 0.347 ✓ 0.343 ✓ 0.368 ✓ 0.374 ✓ 0.358 ✓ 0.345 ✓ 0.349 ✓ 0.342 ✓ 0.345 ✓ 0.351 ✓ 0.357 13 0.351 0.008 ✓
101 ParAAM-C-set 32 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.391 ✓ 0.346 ✓ 0.349 ✓ 0.348 ✓ 0.349 ✓ 0.38  ✓ 0.358 ✓ 0.344 ✓ 0.373 ✓ 0.35  ✓ 0.355 ✓ 0.341 ✓ 0.343 13 0.356 0.012 ✓
102 ParAAM-C-part 1 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 1.39  ✓ 1.416 ✓ 1.383 ✓ 1.402 ✓ 1.36  ✓ 1.378 ✓ 1.386 ✓ 1.355 ✓ 1.379 ✓ 1.345 ✓ 1.34  ✓ 1.34  ✓ 1.389 13 1.374 0.02  ✓
103 ParAAM-C-part 2 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.807 ✓ 0.803 ✓ 0.806 ✓ 0.78  ✓ 0.779 ✓ 0.769 ✓ 0.769 ✓ 0.78  ✓ 0.766 ✓ 0.797 ✓ 0.793 ✓ 0.77  ✓ 0.783 13 0.785 0.012 ✓
104 ParAAM-C-part 3 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.593 ✓ 0.586 ✓ 0.592 ✓ 0.572 ✓ 0.587 ✓ 0.586 ✓ 0.574 ✓ 0.593 ✓ 0.584 ✓ 0.588 ✓ 0.579 ✓ 0.605 ✓ 0.598 13 0.587 0.007 ✓
105 ParAAM-C-part 4 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.502 ✓ 0.495 ✓ 0.481 ✓ 0.468 ✓ 0.469 ✓ 0.49  ✓ 0.486 ✓ 0.512 ✓ 0.487 ✓ 0.497 ✓ 0.479 ✓ 0.486 ✓ 0.476 13 0.487 0.01  ✓
106 ParAAM-C-part 5 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.43  ✓ 0.41  ✓ 0.424 ✓ 0.414 ✓ 0.427 ✓ 0.429 ✓ 0.432 ✓ 0.437 ✓ 0.439 ✓ 0.419 ✓ 0.428 ✓ 0.447 ✓ 0.43  13 0.428 0.007 ✓
107 ParAAM-C-part 6 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.387 ✓ 0.386 ✓ 0.392 ✓ 0.403 ✓ 0.381 ✓ 0.39  ✓ 0.394 ✓ 0.376 ✓ 0.383 ✓ 0.396 ✓ 0.395 ✓ 0.384 ✓ 0.39  13 0.389 0.006 ✓
108 ParAAM-C-part 7 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.35  ✓ 0.343 ✓ 0.344 ✓ 0.346 ✓ 0.342 ✓ 0.345 ✓ 0.346 ✓ 0.344 ✓ 0.354 ✓ 0.347 ✓ 0.347 ✓ 0.336 ✓ 0.341 13 0.345 0.003 ✓
109 ParAAM-C-part 8 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.317 ✓ 0.315 ✓ 0.316 ✓ 0.309 ✓ 0.314 ✓ 0.317 ✓ 0.326 ✓ 0.313 ✓ 0.317 ✓ 0.308 ✓ 0.309 ✓ 0.314 ✓ 0.312 13 0.314 0.003 ✓
110 ParAAM-C-part 9 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.316 ✓ 0.307 ✓ 0.303 ✓ 0.299 ✓ 0.311 ✓ 0.317 ✓ 0.31  ✓ 0.319 ✓ 0.323 ✓ 0.318 ✓ 0.31  ✓ 0.307 ✓ 0.325 13 0.313 0.007 ✓
111 ParAAM-C-part 10 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.311 ✓ 0.317 ✓ 0.311 ✓ 0.312 ✓ 0.324 ✓ 0.307 ✓ 0.305 ✓ 0.331 ✓ 0.314 ✓ 0.317 ✓ 0.312 ✓ 0.307 ✓ 0.319 13 0.314 0.006 ✓
112 ParAAM-C-part 12 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.311 ✓ 0.298 ✓ 0.302 ✓ 0.309 ✓ 0.335 ✓ 0.304 ✓ 0.301 ✓ 0.32  ✓ 0.306 ✓ 0.306 ✓ 0.332 ✓ 0.302 ✓ 0.311 13 0.311 0.009 ✓
113 ParAAM-C-part 14 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.313 ✓ 0.315 ✓ 0.301 ✓ 0.289 ✓ 0.312 ✓ 0.292 ✓ 0.31  ✓ 0.294 ✓ 0.297 ✓ 0.286 ✓ 0.294 ✓ 0.29  ✓ 0.294 13 0.299 0.009 ✓
114 ParAAM-C-part 16 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.289 ✓ 0.288 ✓ 0.284 ✓ 0.284 ✓ 0.285 ✓ 0.282 ✓ 0.289 ✓ 0.307 ✓ 0.297 ✓ 0.288 ✓ 0.276 ✓ 0.306 ✓ 0.293 13 0.29  0.007 ✓
115 ParAAM-C-part 24 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.324 ✓ 0.27  ✓ 0.275 ✓ 0.273 ✓ 0.273 ✓ 0.287 ✓ 0.278 ✓ 0.274 ✓ 0.273 ✓ 0.274 ✓ 0.282 ✓ 0.285 ✓ 0.28  13 0.281 0.009 ✓
116 ParAAM-C-part 32 75879 0 0 1 1 {#f,#t} 13 ✓ 0.285 ✓ 0.28  ✓ 0.277 ✓ 0.276 ✓ 0.287 ✓ 0.271 ✓ 0.319 ✓ 0.287 ✓ 0.281 ✓ 0.28  ✓ 0.28  ✓ 0.285 ✓ 0.279 13 0.284 0.007 ✓